Estimating effectiveness of school-based counselling : using data from controlled trials to predict improvement over non-intervention change

Cooper, Mick and Fugard, Andrew J.B. and Pybis, Jo and McArthur, Katherine and Pearce, Peter (2015) Estimating effectiveness of school-based counselling : using data from controlled trials to predict improvement over non-intervention change. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research, 15 (4). pp. 262-273. ISSN 1473-3145 (https://doi.org/10.1002/capr.12017)

[thumbnail of Cooper-etal-CPR-2015-Estimating-effectiveness-of-school-based-counselling]
Preview
 Text. Filename: Cooper_etal_CPR_2015_Estimating_effectiveness_of_school_based_counselling.pdf
Accepted Author Manuscript
Download (194kB)| Preview

Abstract

Background: There is a growing body of data to show that participation in school-based counselling is associated with significant reductions in psychological distress. However, this cannot be taken as evidence that school-based counselling is effective, as improvements may have happened without the intervention. Aims: The purpose of this study was to develop a method of estimating the amount of ‘natural’ change that might be expected in young people who would attend school-based counselling, such that the effects of the intervention over and above this amount could be identified. Method: Young Person's CORE (YP-CORE) scores from 74 participants allocated to waiting list control conditions in four pilot trials of school-based counselling in the UK were re-analysed using regression models, and a formula was found for estimating the outcomes for young people were they not to receive counselling. This was termed their Estimated Non-intervention Outcome (ENO), and could then be compared against the young person's Actual Outcome (AO), to give an estimated intervention effect (EIE). Results: The formula for the ENO was 4.17 + 0.64 × baseline score. Using this, we calculated a mean EIE for 256 young people in a cohort evaluation study of school-based counselling, which showed that the counselling was associated with large and significantly greater change than would be expected without the intervention (Cohen's d = 0.91). Discussion: The method presented in this paper is a simple means for improving the accuracy of estimations of treatment effectiveness, helping to adjust for changes due to spontaneous recovery and other non-treatment effects.

ORCID iDs

Cooper, Mick, Fugard, Andrew J.B., Pybis, Jo, McArthur, Katherine ORCID logoORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8076-7583 and Pearce, Peter;
CORE (COnnecting REpositories)