The effects of adult guidance and peer discussion on the development of children's representations

Tolmie, Andrew and Thomson, James A. and Foot, Hugh C. and Whelan, Kirstie and Morrison, Sheila and McLaren, Brian (2005) The effects of adult guidance and peer discussion on the development of children's representations. British Journal of Psychology, 96 (2). pp. 181-204. ISSN 0007-1269

[img]
Preview
Text (Tolmie-etal-BJP-2005-The-effect-of-adult-guidance-and-peer-discussion-on-the-development)
Tolmie_etal_BJP_2005_The_effect_of_adult_guidance_and_peer_discussion_on_the_development.pdf
Accepted Author Manuscript

Download (376kB)| Preview

    Abstract

    It was hypothesized that practical training is effective in improving children's pedestrian skills because adult scaffolding and peer discussion during training specifically promote E3 level representation (linguistically-encoded, experientially-grounded, generalizable knowledge), as defined by Karmiloff-Smith's (1992) representational redescription (RR) model. Two studies were conducted to examine in detail the impact of this social input in the context of simulation-based training in roadside search skills. A group of 5-8-year-olds were pre-tested on ability to detect relevant road-crossing features. They then participated in four training sessions designed to promote attunement to these, under peer discussion versus adult guidance conditions (Study 1), and adult-child versus adult-group conditions (Study 2). Performance at post-test was compared with that of controls who underwent no training. Study 1 found that children in the adult guidance condition improved significantly more than those in the peer discussion or control conditions, and this improvement was directly attributable to appropriation of E3 level representations from adult dialogue. Study 2 found that progress was greater still when adult scaffolding was supplemented by peer discussion, with E3 level representation attributable to the children's exploration of conflicting ideas. The implications of these findings for the RR model and for practical road safety education are discussed.