Credibility contests : media debates on do-it-yourself coronavirus responses and the role of citizens in health crises

Erikainen, Sonja and Stewart, Ellen (2020) Credibility contests : media debates on do-it-yourself coronavirus responses and the role of citizens in health crises. Frontiers in Sociology, 5. 91. ISSN 2297-7775 (https://doi.org/10.3389/fsoc.2020.592666)

[thumbnail of Erikainen-Stewart-FS-2020-Credibility-contests-media-debates-on-do-it-yourself-coronavirus-responses]
Preview
 Text. Filename: Erikainen_Stewart_FS_2020_Credibility_contests_media_debates_on_do_it_yourself_coronavirus_responses.pdf
Final Published Version
License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 logo
Download (653kB)| Preview

Abstract

During the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic in Europe and North America, news outlets ran a series of stories reporting on "do-it-yourself" (DIY) coronavirus responses that were created and implemented by citizens. This news discourse exemplifies and can illuminate wider shifts in the roles of citizens in science, as individual outside professional science institutions are becoming more actively involved in scientific knowledge production than before, while the epistemic authority of professional "expert" scientists has been increasingly contested. This paper focuses on DIY citizenship, taking news discourses on citizens' DIY coronavirus responses as a lens to explore wider questions around the changing ways in which the roles of different public health actors are delineated and represented under conditions of significant social and epistemic uncertainty. We aim to shed new light on the nature of – and the role of the news media in mediating – the credibility contests and boundary work that is currently at play around DIY citizenship. We do so by focusing on four discourses: polarised discourses around DIY face masks and hand sanitisers; delineation of credible from incredible interventions and actors around DIY coronavirus treatments and tests; delineation of professional science from "fringe" citizen science; and discourses declaring that "we’re all in this together." We conclude that making sense of these discourses requires a thorough appreciation of the context in which they emerged. Our analysis reveals how emancipatory accounts of DIY citizenship can mask structural inequalities underlying who can and is expected to "do-it-themselves," and how.

CORE (COnnecting REpositories)