Empathic reflection

Elliott, Robert and Bohart, Art and Larson, Dale and Muntigl, Peter and Smoliak, Olga; Hill, Clara and Norcross, John, eds. (2022) Empathic reflection. In: Psychotherapy Skills and Methods That Work. Oxford University Press, Oxford. (In Press)

[thumbnail of Elliott-etal-2023-Empathic-reflections] Text. Filename: Elliott_etal_2023_Empathic_reflections.pdf
Accepted Author Manuscript
Restricted to Repository staff only until 28 September 2023.
License: Strathprints license 1.0

Download (430kB) | Request a copy

Abstract

Therapist empathic reflections are used to communicate understanding of client communications and experiences. Originally associated with person-centered and experiential psychotherapies, they have been adopted by psychotherapists from a range of approaches. We begin with definitions and subtypes of empathic reflection, drawing on relevant research and theory, including conversation analysis. We distinguish between the response mode empathic reflection, reviewed here, and the relational quality of empathy (reviewed in previous meta-analyses). We look at how empathic reflections are assessed and present examples of successful and unsuccessful empathic reflections, also providing a framework of the different criteria used to assess their effectiveness. In our meta-analysis of 43 samples, we found virtually no relation between empathic reflection and effectiveness, both overall and separately for each of six effectiveness criteria. Although not statistically significant, we did find weak support for reflections of change talk and summary reflections. We hypothesize that good and poor reflections routinely cancel each other within studies, indicating the need to look more carefully at the quality of empathy sequences in which empathic reflections are ideally calibrated in response to empathic opportunities offered by clients and sensitively adjusted in response to client confirmation/disconfirmation. We conclude with diversity considerations, research limitations, training implications, and therapeutic practices.

ORCID iDs

Elliott, Robert ORCID logoORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3527-3397, Bohart, Art, Larson, Dale, Muntigl, Peter and Smoliak, Olga; Hill, Clara and Norcross, John