"Fair and balanced" : What news audiences in four countries mean when they say they prefer impartial news

Mont'Alverne, Camila and Badrinathan, Sumitra and Ross Arguedas, Amy and Toff, Benjamin and Fletcher, Richard and Kleis Nielsen, Rasmus (2023) "Fair and balanced" : What news audiences in four countries mean when they say they prefer impartial news. Journalism Studies, 24 (9). pp. 1131-1148. ISSN 1461-670X (https://doi.org/10.1080/1461670X.2023.2201864)

[thumbnail of Mont-Alverne-etal-JS-2023-Fair-and-balanced-what-news-audiences-in-four]
Preview
 Text. Filename: Mont-Alverne-etal-JS-2023-Fair-and-balanced-what-news-audiences-in-four.pdf
Final Published Version
License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 logo
Download (720kB)| Preview

Abstract

Impartial news, or news without a partisan slant or overt point-of-view, is overwhelmingly preferred by news audiences worldwide, yet what such preferences mean remains poorly understood. In this study, we examine what people mean when they say they prefer impartial news. We draw on qualitative interviews and focus groups with 132 individuals in Brazil, India, the UK, and the US, conducted in early 2021. Our results show while the idea of impartial news is widely embraced in abstract, ranging from notions of reporting "just the facts" to more nuanced views about how feasible impartiality is to achieve, there is no shared understanding of impartiality in practice. People's perceptions of impartiality are rooted in two intertwined folk theories: the notion that news production and editorial decisions are guided largely by (a) partisan political agendas or (b) commercial considerations, determining what stories were chosen, ignored, or crafted in order to deceive and manipulate. There is some country variation around the importance of these folk theories, but their recurrence suggests that demonstrating impartiality to audiences requires convincing them not only that news content is balanced but also that editorial decisions were not driven by ulterior motives.

ORCID iDs

Mont'Alverne, Camila ORCID logoORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6100-4879, Badrinathan, Sumitra, Ross Arguedas, Amy, Toff, Benjamin, Fletcher, Richard and Kleis Nielsen, Rasmus;
CORE (COnnecting REpositories)