Not 'radical', but not 'kailyard' either : the Paisley Community Development Project reconsidered

Crow, Graham and Rawcliffe, Sue and Harris, Bernard (2019) Not 'radical', but not 'kailyard' either : the Paisley Community Development Project reconsidered. Community Development Journal, 54 (3). pp. 501-518. ISSN 0010-3802 (

[thumbnail of Crow-etal-CDJ-2018-Not-radical-but-not-kailyard-either-the-Paisley-community]
Text. Filename: Crow_etal_CDJ_2018_Not_radical_but_not_kailyard_either_the_Paisley_community.pdf
Final Published Version
License: Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 logo

Download (314kB)| Preview


Accounts of the Community Development Projects (CDPs) that ran as experimental interventions in twelve deprived UK localities in the 1970s concentrate on those projects identified as 'radical'. Focusing on the often-neglected history of Paisley's CDP, this article extends recent critical re-evaluations of how CDPs have been characterised. Ferguslie Park in Paisley was the most disadvantaged of the CDP areas on several criteria, and the only CDP to be based in an outer-urban area, as well as being distinct in further ways. This influenced how the CDP team devised its community development strategy, which is misunderstood when treated as embodying a parochial 'kailyard' mentality. Paisley’s CDP has continuing relevance to debates about area-based policy and public involvement in research as they are rehearsed in new contexts.