Economic voting through boom and bust : information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011

Bernhagen, Patrick and Brandenburg, Heinz; Marsh, Michael and Farrell, David M. and McElroy, Gail, eds. (2017) Economic voting through boom and bust : information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011. In: A Conservative Revolution? Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 42-60. ISBN 9780198744030

[thumbnail of Bernhagen-Brandenburg-2017-Economic-voting-through-boom-and-bust]
Text. Filename: Bernhagen_Brandenburg_2017_Economic_voting_through_boom_and_bust.pdf
Accepted Author Manuscript

Download (475kB)| Preview


A considerable body of research exists on the economic and informational determinants of voting behaviour. However, unresolved questions remain about the relationship between these two factors. While economic voting is generally understood as a matter of prospective evaluation carried out on the basis of retrospective cues available to voters, the extent to which prospective information matters for vote choice remains unclear, in particular if it conflicts with retrospective experience. How do different sources of information compete to affect vote choice and evaluations of incumbents? Specifically, how do voters evaluate incumbents if past economic performance has been good but predictions about the near future are bleak? In this chapter we address this question by analysing the economic and informational determinants of vote choice at three successive Irish elections: the last two general elections before the fiscal and economic collapse and the first election following the meltdown. Jointly, these elections form a quasi-experimental case study of economic votingthatenablesustoinvestigatewhethertheextenttowhichvotersreward the government for facilitating an economic boom is affected by warnings about precarious foundations and predictions of economic decline. To analyse this potentially contingent relationship we link media content data in the context of the elections with survey data from the Irish National Election Study (INES). The three election campaigns are marked by significant variation in the amount (and, for two elections, in the tone) of economic


Bernhagen, Patrick and Brandenburg, Heinz ORCID logoORCID:; Marsh, Michael, Farrell, David M. and McElroy, Gail