Picture of smart phone

Open Access research that is better understanding human-computer interaction...

Strathprints makes available scholarly Open Access content by researchers in the Department of Computer & Information Sciences, including those researching information retrieval, information behaviour, user behaviour and ubiquitous computing.

The Department of Computer & Information Sciences hosts The Mobiquitous Lab, which investigates user behaviour on mobile devices and emerging ubiquitous computing paradigms. The Strathclyde iSchool Research Group specialises in understanding how people search for information and explores interactive search tools that support their information seeking and retrieval tasks, this also includes research into information behaviour and engagement.

Explore the Open Access research of The Mobiquitous Lab and the iSchool, or theDepartment of Computer & Information Sciences more generally. Or explore all of Strathclyde's Open Access research...

Complementary logics of target-setting : hierarchist and experimentalist governance in the Scottish National Health Service

Schang, Laura and Morton, Alec (2017) Complementary logics of target-setting : hierarchist and experimentalist governance in the Scottish National Health Service. Health Economics, Policy and Law, 12 (1). pp. 21-41. ISSN 1744-134X

[img]
Preview
Text (Schang-Morton-HEPL-2016-Complementary-logics-of-target-setting-hierarchist)
Schang_Morton_HEPL_2016_Complementary_logics_of_target_setting_hierarchist.pdf
Accepted Author Manuscript

Download (684kB) | Preview

Abstract

Where policy ends are contested and means for change are ambiguous, imposing central targets on local organisations – what we call hierarchist governance – is problematic. The concept of experimentalist governance suggests that target-setting should rather be a learning process between central regulators and local organisations. However, the relationship between experimentalist and hierarchist governance remains unclear. Existing literature suggests that the learning-oriented experimentalist logic is hard to reconcile with a hierarchist logic focussed on accountability for results. We examine whether complementary use of hierarchist and experimentalist ideas is possible. Drawing on experiences from Scotland, we find that experimentalist and hierarchist logics can co-exist in the same performance management system. Each logic served distinct roles with respect to target-setting, implementation and accountability. The emphasis on experimentalism was stronger where ends and means were contested (the case of shifting the balance of care for older people) than where both ends and means seemed obvious initially (the case of healthcare-associated infections, where target-setting followed a more hierarchist logic). However, governance drifted towards experimentalism when rising rates of community-acquired infections decreased clarity about effective interventions. The nature of policy issues and changes therein over time appear to be important conditions for synergies between governance logics.