In good conscience : conscience-based exemptions and proper medical treatment
Fovargue, Sara and Neal, Mary (2015) In good conscience : conscience-based exemptions and proper medical treatment. Medical Law Review, 23 (2). pp. 221-241. ISSN 0967-0742 (https://doi.org/10.1093/medlaw/fwv007)
Preview |
Text.
Filename: Fovargue_Neal_MLR_2015_In_good_conscience_conscience_based_exemptions_and_proper_medical.pdf
Accepted Author Manuscript Download (394kB)| Preview |
Abstract
Lack of clarity about the proper limits of conscientious refusal to participate in particular healthcare practices has given rise to fears that, in the absence of clear parameters, conscience-based exemptions may become increasingly widespread, leading to intolerable burdens on health professionals, patients, and institutions. Here, we identify three factors which clarify the proper scope of conscience-based exemptions: the liminal zone of ‘proper medical treatment’ as their territorial extent; some criteria for genuine conscientiousness; and the fact that the exercise of a valid conscience-based exemption carries certain duties with it. These restricting factors should reassure those who worry that recognising rights of conscience at all inevitably risks rampant subjectivity and self-interest on the part of professionals. At the same time, they delineate a robust conscience zone: where a claim of conscience relates to treatment with liminal status and satisfies the criteria for conscientious character, as well as the conditions for conscientious performance, it deserves muscular legal protection.
-
-
Item type: Article ID code: 53902 Dates: DateEvent2015Published5 May 2015Published Online6 March 2015AcceptedSubjects: Law
MedicineDepartment: Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences (HaSS) > Strathclyde Law School > Law Depositing user: Pure Administrator Date deposited: 28 Jul 2015 15:18 Last modified: 19 Mar 2024 01:59 URI: https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/id/eprint/53902