Picture of server farm and IT infrastructure

Where technology & law meet: Open Access research on data security & its regulation ...

Strathprints makes available Open Access scholarly outputs exploring both the technical aspects of computer security, but also the regulation of existing or emerging technologies. A research specialism of the Department of Computer & Information Sciences (CIS) is computer security. Researchers explore issues surrounding web intrusion detection techniques, malware characteristics, textual steganography and trusted systems. Digital forensics and cyber crime are also a focus.

Meanwhile, the School of Law and its Centre for Internet Law & Policy undertake studies on Internet governance. An important component of this work is consideration of privacy and data protection questions and the increasing focus on cybercrime and 'cyberterrorism'.

Explore the Open Access research by CIS on computer security or the School of Law's work on law, technology and regulation. Or explore all of Strathclyde's Open Access research...

Measurement issues in the evaluation of projects in a project portfolio

Morton, Alec (2015) Measurement issues in the evaluation of projects in a project portfolio. European Journal of Operational Research, 245 (3). pp. 789-796. ISSN 0377-2217

[img]
Preview
Text (Morton-EJOR-2015-Measurement-issues-in-the-evaluation-of-projects)
Morton_EJOR_2015_Measurement_issues_in_the_evaluation_of_projects.pdf
Accepted Author Manuscript
License: Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 logo

Download (301kB) | Preview

Abstract

A common problem in multicriteria decision analysis is how to value projects in a project portfolio. Recently, there has been some attention given to a practice whereby analysts define a value function on some criterion by setting 0 as the value of the worst project. In particular, Clemen and Smith have argued this practice is not sound as it gives different results from the case where projects are "priced out", and makes a strong implicit assumption about the value of not doing a project. Moreover, it can be shown easily that the optimal choice set is not invariant with respect to rescalings such as those induced by the addition of a new item to the choice set, hence rank reversal can occur when this procedure is used. We provide a measurement theoretic account of the phenomenon and show that whether the admissible transformations of the underlying scale are similarity or affine (or other) transformations depends on the precise details of the value model used. We also provide an axiomatic impossibility result which illustrates an incompatibility between an idea that inaction has a value of zero and the admissibility of constant scale translations. We use our analysis to comment on the view of Clemen and Smith that the baseline problem is best dealt with by assigning project-specific scores for not doing particular projects.