Picture of UK Houses of Parliament

Leading national thinking on politics, government & public policy through Open Access research

Strathprints makes available scholarly Open Access content by researchers in the School of Government & Public Policy, based within the Faculty of Humanities & Social Sciences.

Research here is 1st in Scotland for research intensity and spans a wide range of domains. The Department of Politics demonstrates expertise in understanding parties, elections and public opinion, with additional emphases on political economy, institutions and international relations. This international angle is reflected in the European Policies Research Centre (EPRC) which conducts comparative research on public policy. Meanwhile, the Centre for Energy Policy provides independent expertise on energy, working across multidisciplinary groups to shape policy for a low carbon economy.

Explore the Open Access research of the School of Government & Public Policy. Or explore all of Strathclyde's Open Access research...

Lawyer resistance to mediation: a Scottish perspective

Clark, Bryan (2011) Lawyer resistance to mediation: a Scottish perspective. Malaysian Current Law Journal, 2011 (1).

Full text not available in this repository.Request a copy from the Strathclyde author


The issue of lawyer resistance to mediation is one which has blighted the process since the early days of its re-birth in the 1960's USA. While mediation has grown significantly in many jurisdictions globally in recent decades and lawyers heavily populate the mediation field in many contexts both as mediators and as party representatives, simultaneously, lawyers stand accused of acting as a roadblock to mediation's growth. It has been argued that although clearly many lawyers have embraced mediation, many others remain on the fringes apathetic, others are openly sceptical or even anti-mediation in their posturing. Against this backdrop, this paper analyses the notion of lawyer resistance to mediation, the motives of those lawyers who can be seen to have resisted mediation and the impact that any erection of barriers by lawyers has had on, and may in the future hold for mediation practice. While the focus is primarily upon Scotland, the paper also draws on international evidence and indeed my findings may be of relevance to other jurisdictions in which similar issues and trends may be noted. The paper draws on empirical evidence, speculation from academic commentators and others as well as my own observations stemming from 16 years experience in the field, much of which I have spent in conversation with lawyers, mediators, disputants and scholars.