Theorising respect and disrespect by and about children and young people : a qualitative systematic literature review

Tools

MacKenzie, Alison and Fargas, Montserrat and McAlister, Siobhán and Byrne, Bronagh and Cassidy, Claire and Corr, Mary-Louise and Hanna, Amy and Lundy, Laura and Neill, Gail and Schubotz, Dirk (2026) Theorising respect and disrespect by and about children and young people : a qualitative systematic literature review. Children and Society. ISSN 0951-0605 (https://doi.org/10.1111/chso.70031)

[thumbnail of MacKenzie-etal-CS-2026-Theorising-respect-and-disrespect-by-and-about-children-and-young-people]
Preview
 Text. Filename: MacKenzie-etal-CS-2026-Theorising-respect-and-disrespect-by-and-about-children-and-young-people.pdf
Final Published Version
License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 logo
Download (502kB)| Preview

Abstract

Respect is a foundational moral and social value, yet its conceptualisation by and about children and young people remains underexplored. This systematic qualitative literature review examines how respect and disrespect are theorised, defined or conceptualised in relation to children and young people, and the extent to which their perspectives are represented in schools, higher education, care and community settings. Guided by PRISMA protocols, 10 databases were searched, yielding 814 records; 26 peer-reviewed articles met the inclusion criteria. Five overarching themes emerged: (1) Recognition and moral worth, emphasising respect as a universal entitlement and basis for rights; (2) Relational and reciprocal dynamics, highlighting mutuality, dialogue and authentic engagement; (3) Respect as a behavioural, emotional and cultural construct, shaped by norms, authority and gendered expectations; (4) Educational and developmental value, positioning respect as a teachable moral and epistemic virtue; and (5) Social justice, inclusion and power, critiquing top-down, punitive respect agendas that alienate young people. Across contexts, respect was most often conceptualised as relational and care-oriented, expressed through attentiveness, fairness and recognition of individuality. Disrespect, conversely, was linked to misrecognition, exclusion and structural inequalities. Future research should recognise young people as capable of contributing to theoretical and practical understandings of moral principles such as respect.

ORCID iDs

MacKenzie, Alison, Fargas, Montserrat, McAlister, Siobhán, Byrne, Bronagh, Cassidy, Claire ORCID logoORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3088-1721, Corr, Mary-Louise, Hanna, Amy, Lundy, Laura, Neill, Gail and Schubotz, Dirk;
CORE (COnnecting REpositories)