What do indeterminacy and uncertainty mean in landscape research? Perspectives from natural sciences, social sciences, and arts

Tools

Fremantle, Chris and Vergunst, Jo and Barwell, Louise J. and Bevan, Anne and Cavers, Stephen and Clarke, Jennifer and Collins, Timothy M. and Goto Collins, Reiko and Combe, Malcolm M. and Cottrell, Joan and Douglas, Anne and Edwards, David and Ellison, Aaron M. and Heddon, Deirdre and Heim, Wallace and Kalshoven, Petra Tjitske and Marion, Glenn and Oliver, Seth and Saraev, Vadim and Veenman, Sietske (2025) What do indeterminacy and uncertainty mean in landscape research? Perspectives from natural sciences, social sciences, and arts. Landscape Research. pp. 1-19. ISSN 0142-6397 (https://doi.org/10.1080/01426397.2025.2537772)

[thumbnail of Fremantle-etal-LR-2025-What-do-indeterminacy-and-uncertainty-mean-in-landscape-research]
Preview
 Text. Filename: Fremantle-etal-LR-2025-What-do-indeterminacy-and-uncertainty-mean-in-landscape-research.pdf
Final Published Version
License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 logo
Download (2MB)| Preview

Abstract

Landscapes, intentionally or otherwise, are often planned and managed in ways that create determined outcomes involving production, conservation, and aesthetics. While the focus of much research is on how to plan landscapes more effectively, this article explores how uncertainty and indeterminacy are inevitably also part of the research process. We present the results of discussions among a multidisciplinary group of researchers across the arts, humanities, social and natural sciences. We articulate discipline-specific understandings of indeterminacy and uncertainty and synthesise points of similarity and difference between them. Common concerns are with the limits of knowledge; conceptions of futures; the role of chance and change; and the dichotomy of action or ‘doing nothing’ in landscapes. We highlight arts research that works distinctively to develop subjectivities and create different relations with control and management. We emphasise the challenge of research to manage risks versus the need for indeterminacy to enable adaptation and promote novelty.

ORCID iDs

Fremantle, Chris, Vergunst, Jo, Barwell, Louise J., Bevan, Anne, Cavers, Stephen, Clarke, Jennifer, Collins, Timothy M., Goto Collins, Reiko, Combe, Malcolm M. ORCID logoORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1711-9150, Cottrell, Joan, Douglas, Anne, Edwards, David, Ellison, Aaron M., Heddon, Deirdre, Heim, Wallace, Kalshoven, Petra Tjitske, Marion, Glenn, Oliver, Seth, Saraev, Vadim and Veenman, Sietske;
CORE (COnnecting REpositories)