Contrasting effects of high-starch and high-sugar diets on ruminal function in cattle

Francesio, Andrea and Viora, Lorenzo and Denwood, Matt J. and Tulley, Will and Brady, Nicola and Hastie, Peter and Hamilton, Andrew and Davison, Christopher and Michie, Craig and Jonsson, Nicholas N. (2020) Contrasting effects of high-starch and high-sugar diets on ruminal function in cattle. Journal of Dairy Research, 87 (2). pp. 175-183. ISSN 0022-0299 (

[thumbnail of Francesio-etal-JDR-2020-Contrasting-effects-of-high-starch-and-high-sugar-diets]
Text. Filename: Francesio_etal_JDR_2020_Contrasting_effects_of_high_starch_and_high_sugar_diets.pdf
Final Published Version
License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 logo

Download (310kB)| Preview


The experiment reported in this research paper aimed to determine whether clinical and subclinical effects on cattle were similar if provided with isoenergetic and isonitrogenous challenge diets in which carbohydrate sources were predominantly starch or sugar. The study was a 3 × 3 Latin square using six adult Jersey cows with rumen cannulae, over 9 weeks. In the first 2 weeks of each 3 week experimental period cows were fed with a maintenance diet and, in the last week, each animal was assigned to one of three diets: a control diet (CON), being a continuation of the maintenance diet; a high starch (HSt) or a high sugar (HSu) diet. Reticuloruminal pH and motility were recorded throughout the study period. Blood and ruminal samples were taken on day-1 (TP-1), day-2 (TP-2) and day-7 (TP-7) of each challenge week. Four clinical variables were recorded daily: diarrhoea, inappetence, depression and ruminal tympany. The effects of treatment, hour of day and day after treatment on clinical parameters were analysed using linear mixed effects (LME) models. Although both challenge diets resulted in a decline in pH, an increase in the absolute pH residuals and an increase in the number of minutes per day under pH 5.8, systemic inflammation was only detected with the HSt diet. The challenge diets differentially modified amplitude and period of reticuloruminal contractions compared with CON diet and both were associated with an increased probability of diarrhoea. The HSu diet reduced the probability of an animal consuming its complete allocation. Because the challenge diets were derived from complex natural materials (barley and molasses respectively), it is not possible to assign all the differential effects to the difference in starch and sugar concentration: non-starch components of barley or non-sugar components of molasses might have contributed to some of the observations. In conclusion, substituting much of the starch with sugar caused no substantial reduction in the acidosis load, but inflammatory response was reduced while feed rejection was increased.


Francesio, Andrea, Viora, Lorenzo, Denwood, Matt J., Tulley, Will, Brady, Nicola, Hastie, Peter, Hamilton, Andrew ORCID logoORCID:, Davison, Christopher ORCID logoORCID:, Michie, Craig ORCID logoORCID: and Jonsson, Nicholas N.;