Mentor suitability and mentoring relationship quality : lessons from the Glasgow Intergenerational Mentoring Network

McArthur, Katherine and Wilson, Alastair and Hunter, Katie (2016) Mentor suitability and mentoring relationship quality : lessons from the Glasgow Intergenerational Mentoring Network. Journal of Community Psychology. ISSN 0090-4392 (In Press)

Preview

Text (McArthur-etal-JOP-2017-Mentor-suitability-and-mentoring-relationship-quality) McArthur_etal_JOP_2017_Mentor_suitability_and_mentoring_relationship_quality.pdf Accepted Author Manuscript Download (455kB)| Preview

Abstract

The research literature on mentoring is diverse, draws mainly on studies from the US and spans youth, academic and workplace mentoring (Eby et al, 2010). School-based mentoring programmes targeted at socially disadvantaged young people vary from those employing peer mentors, older students and adults of different ages, and show modest positive impacts on outcomes such as truancy, misconduct and academic abilities (Rhodes et al., 2005). A meta-analysis of 73 US mentoring programmes (DuBois et al, 2011) suggested overall effectiveness showing positive outcomes for young people across social, emotional, academic and behavioural domains, and positioning mentoring as having equal effectiveness compared with other forms of youth intervention. Furthermore, the findings showed that young people not engaged in mentoring declined over time on similar outcomes.