Picture child's feet next to pens, pencils and paper

Open Access research that is helping to improve educational outcomes for children

Strathprints makes available scholarly Open Access content by researchers in the School of Education, including those researching educational and social practices in curricular subjects. Research in this area seeks to understand the complex influences that increase curricula capacity and engagement by studying how curriculum practices relate to cultural, intellectual and social practices in and out of schools and nurseries.

Research at the School of Education also spans a number of other areas, including inclusive pedagogy, philosophy of education, health and wellbeing within health-related aspects of education (e.g. physical education and sport pedagogy, autism and technology, counselling education, and pedagogies for mental and emotional health), languages education, and other areas.

Explore Open Access education research. Or explore all of Strathclyde's Open Access research...

The sky is not a cow : interpreting religion beyond the propositional frame

Lewin, David (2016) The sky is not a cow : interpreting religion beyond the propositional frame. In: Philosophy of Education Society of Great Britain, 2016-04-01 - 2016-04-03. (Unpublished)

Text (Lewin-PESGB-2016-interpreting-religion-beyond-the-propositional-frame)
Accepted Author Manuscript

Download (370kB) | Preview


How does our understanding of religion frame discourse about the place of religion in education? Debates between Michael Hand and Trevor Cooling illustrate a tendency within philosophy of education: religion is understood in terms of what I characterize as the ‘propositional frame’. The propositional frame involves a reductive identification of religion with truth claims, belief systems or worldviews. Drawing on philosophers and theologians such as Charles Taylor, Rowan Williams and Wilfred Cantwell Smith, I argue that the ‘problem’ of religion and education is not best understood as involving competing and irreconcilable worldviews. The propositional frame tends to draw the discussion towards questions of indoctrination, or competing rights between parents and children, or parents and the state. In order to move beyond this propositional framing of religion, I suggest we need to see the religion embodied and embedded in practices that James Smith calls ‘cultural liturgies’. Those liturgies – whether religious or secular – are formative and therefore educational. The dangers of leaving formation to the liturgies of secular culture will be briefly explored. The wider context of the paper is to show the sense in which there is no such thing as secular education.