Aid and development : issues and reflections

Tribe, Michael (2013) Aid and development : issues and reflections. Strathclyde Discussion Papers in Economics (13-09). ISSN 0959-5635

[thumbnail of 13-09FINAL] PDF (13-09FINAL)
13_09FINAL.pdf
Final Published Version

Download (285kB)

    Abstract

    The paper has three main sections. The first is a review of two particular propositions which appear in Dambisa Moyo’s 2009 book Dead Aid which were not subjected to rigorous analysis in the reviews which appeared following its publication. The finding is that neither proposition survives serious scrutiny – that aid is responsible for most of sub-Saharan Africa’s economic woes and that the international bond market represents a viable alternative to foreign aid for the finance of development-oriented investment. The second questions some of the characteristics and uses of the World Bank’s Country Policy and Institutional Assessment (CPIA), particularly focussing on the use of an essentially ordinal measure in cardinal applications. The third subjects the UK Department for International Development’s Needs-Effectiveness Index to critical review, concluding that further consideration of its attributes is necessary.