%PDF-1.3
%
1 0 obj
<< /Length 778 >>
stream
lw-ltlogo.eps
endstream
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/MetaData 1 0 R
/Title (lw-ltlogo.eps)
/Creator (Adobe Illustrator\(R\) 8.0)
/Author (laser)
>>
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Parent 18 0 R
/Resources 5 0 R
/Contents 4 0 R
/Thumb 108 0 R
>>
endobj
4 0 obj
<< /Length 13673 >>
stream
0 g
/GS1 gs
q
23.94 0 0 -0.54 18.294 889.176 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
0.54 0 0 -18.72 56.394 921.516 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
0 G
0 J 0 j 0.5 w 4 M []0 d
/GS2 gs
3 i
330.5 914.79 m
378.5 914.79 l
354.5 926.79 m
354.5 902.79 l
354.493 908.797 m
357.806 908.797 360.493 911.484 360.493 914.797 c
360.493 918.111 357.806 920.797 354.493 920.797 c
351.179 920.797 348.493 918.111 348.493 914.797 c
348.493 911.484 351.179 908.797 354.493 908.797 c
s
/GS1 gs
q
0.54 0 0 -18.72 652.134 921.516 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
23.94 0 0 -0.54 666.834 889.176 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
/GS2 gs
29.957 444.183 m
29.957 492.183 l
17.957 468.183 m
41.957 468.183 l
35.95 468.175 m
35.95 471.489 33.264 474.175 29.95 474.175 c
26.637 474.175 23.95 471.489 23.95 468.175 c
23.95 464.862 26.637 462.175 29.95 462.175 c
33.264 462.175 35.95 464.862 35.95 468.175 c
h
678.557 444.183 m
678.557 492.183 l
666.557 468.183 m
690.557 468.183 l
684.55 468.175 m
684.55 471.489 681.863 474.175 678.55 474.175 c
675.236 474.175 672.55 471.489 672.55 468.175 c
672.55 464.862 675.236 462.175 678.55 462.175 c
681.863 462.175 684.55 464.862 684.55 468.175 c
s
/GS1 gs
q
23.94 0 0 -0.54 18.294 47.3161 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
0.54 0 0 -18.72 56.394 32.6161 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
/GS2 gs
330.5 25.35 m
378.5 25.35 l
354.5 37.35 m
354.5 13.35 l
354.493 19.357 m
357.806 19.357 360.493 22.044 360.493 25.357 c
360.493 28.671 357.806 31.357 354.493 31.357 c
351.179 31.357 348.493 28.671 348.493 25.357 c
348.493 22.044 351.179 19.357 354.493 19.357 c
s
/GS1 gs
q
0.54 0 0 -18.72 652.134 32.6161 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
23.94 0 0 -0.54 666.834 47.3161 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F1 1 Tf
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 110.04 816.99 Tm
0.0011 Tc
0 Tw
(136)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
2.665 0 TD
0.0002 Tc
[(RODGER)-8(:)-271.4(COMPETITION)-281(L)1.4(AW)-279.6(LITIGATION:)-286.4(UK)-271.5(COURT)-274.8(CASES)-282.7(20052008PART)-267.3(II:)-278.9([2009])-276.6(G.C.L.R.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
22.3163 0 0 27.8954 110.04 757.53 Tm
-0.0004 Tc
[(Competition)-278.5(L)1.1(aw)]TJ
0 -1.0002 TD
[(Litigation)-278.5(in)-278.5(the)]TJ
T*
0.0001 Tc
[(UK)-275.4(Courts:)-278.4(A)-277.4(study)]TJ
T*
-0.0008 Tc
[(of)-278.1(all)-277.8(cases)]TJ
T*
0.0004 Tc
[(20052008Part)-274(II)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12.5529 0 0 17.9327 110.04 611.1301 Tm
-0.0002 Tc
[(Professor)-274.2(B)1.3(arry)-279.2(J.)-281.4(Rodger)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
17.9327 0 0 17.9327 254.8187 611.1301 Tm
0 Tc
(*)Tj
ET
/EmbeddedDocument /MC1 BDC
q
5.793 i
110.04 565.356 20.618 -11.474 re
W n
/GS2 gs
q
21.8777 0 0 12.1946 110.04 553.4543 cm
/Im3 Do
Q
EMC
Q
BT
/F2 1 Tf
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 136.98 553.77 Tm
-0.0007 Tc
[([Keywords)-286.2(t)1.1(o)-275.8(F)2.2(ollow])]TJ
-2.7041 -3.6135 TD
[(Part)-703.5(II)-704.5(of)-703.5(this)-707.7(article)-700.9(c)-2.3(ontinues)-713.7(t)1.2(he)-706.9(discussion)-703.3(of)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0005 Tc
[(all)-487.4(c)-2.2(ompetition)-492.4(law)-487.2(c)-2.2(ases)-484.8(before)-484(the)-496(domestic)-484(c)-2.2(ourts)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0013 Tc
[(of)-625.9(the)-623.3(U)-2(nited)-625.7(K)-2(ingdom,)-632.7(i)-0.3(ncluding)-633.5(the)-623.3(C)-2(ompetition)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
0.0002 Tc
[(Appeal)-342.1(Tribunal)-348.1(\()2(CAT\),)-336.1(w)1.3(here)-344.8(parties)-345.5(w)1.3(ere)-338.7(s)-2.3(eeking)-343(t)2(o)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0001 Tc
[(exercise)-278.8(rights)-291.6(conferred)-281.2(o)1.8(n)-293.3(t)1.7(hem)-288.3(b)1.8(y)-289.1(e)-1.8(ither)-291.6(C)-0.8(ommunity)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(or)-659.9(UK)-664.2(competition)-667.6(l)0(aw)-662.4(in)-661.6(the)-665.1(p)0.9(eriod)-661.6(20052008.)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0006 Tc
[(Part)-836(I)-830.9(outlined)-847.9(the)-839.4(b)1.3(ackground)-841.8(developments)-840.2(in)]TJ
T*
[(private)-562.4(e)-2.3(nforcement)-552.9(g)-0.5(enerally,)-559.7(t)1.2(he)-562.4(methodology)-572.6(a)-0.5(nd)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
0 Tc
[(identication)-401.6(o)1.9(f)-389.7(a)0.1(ppropriate)-399.2(cases,)-378.5(the)-399.2(g)0.1(eneral)-384.5(success)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0005 Tc
[(rates)-255.9(a)-0.4(nd)-257.5(also)-251.5(the)-261.1(r)-3(ole)-261.1(o)1.4(f)-257.7(d)1.4(if)19.3(ferent)-257.7(courts)-261.9(in)-257.5(competition)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.001 Tc
[(litigation,)-457.7(in)-444.7(particular)-449.1(focusing)-452.6(on)-450.8(follow-on)-456.8(actions)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
0.0008 Tc
[(before)-801.9(the)-801.9(C)0.1(AT.)-793.2(P)2.7(art)-804.5(I)1.6(I)-799.4(a)0.9(ssesses)-784.6(t)2.6(he)-801.9(success)-796.6(o)2.7(f)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
0.0001 Tc
[(competition)-612.3(l)1.1(aw)-613.1(issues)-604.6(raised)-600.2(at)-606.4(dif)19.9(f)1.9(erent)-612.4(s)-2.4(tages)-604.6(o)2(f)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0003 Tc
[(the)-501.8(litigation)-516.3(p)1.6(rocess,)-493.2(the)-501.8(e)-2(xtent)-504.4(t)1.5(o)-504.3(w)0.8(hich)-504.3(particular)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
[(competition)-661(l)0.6(aws)-653.3(h)1.5(ave)-652.5(been)-654.9(relied)-648.9(o)1.5(n)-654.9(i)0.6(n)-648.9(litigation)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
0.0002 Tc
[(and)-551.9(t)2(heir)-550.3(relative)-549.5(success)-544.3(a)0.3(nd)-551.9(the)-555.5(d)2.1(egree)-543.5(o)2.1(f)-552.1(s)-2.3(uccess)]TJ
T*
-0.0001 Tc
[(according)-343.3(t)1.7(o)-347.5(t)1.7(he)-345.1(remedies)-339.8(sought.)-348.4(T)-2.6(he)-339(article)-345.1(p)1.8(roceeds)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
[(to)-347.5(consider)-345.9(key)-349.3(t)1.7(hemes)-351.9(w)1(hich)-347.5(may)-349.3(a)0(ct)-341.6(as)-351.9(incentives)-345.9(o)1.8(r)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0009 Tc
[(disincentives)-328.6(t)0.9(o)-330.2(c)-2.6(ompetition)-330.2(law)-331.1(litigation,)-337.2(focusing)-332(on)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0007 Tc
[(the)-387.8(i)0.3(ssues)-376.6(of)-384.4(funding)-398.1(and)-384.2(c)-2.4(osts)-382.6(of)-384.4(litigation,)-397.2(discovery)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0001 Tc
[(processes,)-330.4(the)-345.1(t)1.7(ype)-351.1(o)1.8(f)-341.6(d)1.8(amages)-345.8(available)-351.1(a)0(nd)-341.5(collective)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0004 Tc
[(redress,)-360.8(before)-375.5(drawing)-379.7(c)-2.1(onclusions)-382.3(about)-378.1(the)-381.5(s)-2.9(tate)-375.5(of)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0008 Tc
[(development)-571.2(o)1.1(f)-571.2(c)-2.5(ompetition)-577(litigation)-577(i)0.2(n)-565(t)1(he)-574.6(United)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.001 Tc
(Kingdom.)Tj
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 127.98 194.67 Tm
-0.0004 Tc
[(*)-551(U)-1.1(niversity)-622.1(of)-623.5(Strathclyde,)-625.8(Gl)]TJ
14.4164 0 TD
-0.0001 Tc
[(asgow,)-633(barry.j.rodger@strath.)]TJ
-14.4164 -1.1819 TD
0.0007 Tc
[(a)3.8(c)0.5(.uk.)-541.9(T)4.2(h)-0.4(a)3.8(nks)-543.8(to)-542.4(my)-538.2(resea)3.8(r)-1.8(ch)-542.4(a)3.8(ssista)3.8(n)-0.4(t,)-541.9(D)3.3(i)0.2(a)3.8(nne)-541.5(McFa)3.8(ll,)-549.4(for)]TJ
0 -1.1894 TD
0.0003 Tc
[(assistance)-556.9(in)-565.4(compiling)-553.6(t)2.1(he)-564.5(case)-564.5(database.)-564.9(T)3.8(his)-566.8(i)-0.2(s)-566.8(a)-561.2(revised)]TJ
T*
0.0002 Tc
[(version)-271.9(of)-276.6(a)-282.7(p)-0.9(aper)-280.8(presented)-271.9(a)3.3(t)-284.1(a)-275.2(George)-278.5(Washington)-279.4(University)]TJ
T*
0.0005 Tc
(Conference,)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
5.7063 0 TD
0.0001 Tc
[(Private)-542.1(E)-2.9(nforcement)-532.6(o)-1(f)-532.6(C)-0.6(ompetition)-535.5(Law:)-542.5(New)]TJ
-5.7063 -1.1819 TD
0.0008 Tc
(Directions)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
4.5094 0 TD
0.0007 Tc
[(,)-263.3(F)0.6(ebruary)-274.7(2728,)-278.4(2009.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
11.1582 0 0 13.9477 360.9 767.79 Tm
0.0009 Tc
[(Success)-268.7(a)-0.5(t)-276.2(d)-1.1(if)22(ferent)-270.9(stages)-268.7(of)-279.1(the)-274.7(litigation)]TJ
0 -1.1787 TD
0.001 Tc
(process)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 360.9 725.49 Tm
0 Tc
[(We)-483.5(considered)-485.9(the)-489.5(s)-2.5(uccess)-478.2(o)1.9(f)-486.1(c)-1.7(ompetition)-491.9(law)-486.7(i)1(ssues)]TJ
0 -1.2466 TD
-0.0002 Tc
[(in)-425.9(four)-436.3(categories)-424.2(according)-427.7(t)1.6(o)-431.9(d)1.7(if)19.6(ferent)-426(stages)-430.3(o)1.7(f)-426(t)1.6(he)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0001 Tc
[(litigation)-341.5(p)1.8(rocess.)-330.4(The)-333(m)0.8(ost)-335.6(s)-2.6(traightforward)-335.4(i)0.9(nvolves)-339.8(a)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0008 Tc
[(substantive)-237.3(nal)-234.7(j)0.2(udgment)-239.9(on)-233.8(the)-237.3(c)-2.5(ompetition)-239.8(law)-234.6(i)0.2(ssue,)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0009 Tc
[(normally)-434.4(following)-440.4(trial.)]TJ
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 469.62 679.29 Tm
0 Tc
(1)Tj
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 477.72 675.6901 Tm
0.0002 Tc
[(Inevitably,)-438.5(t)2(hese)-429.1(cases)-417.8(h)2.1(ave)]TJ
-11.7258 -1.2467 TD
0.0003 Tc
[(generally)-391(attracted)-389.2(g)0.4(reates)]TJ
11.5091 0 TD
-0.0007 Tc
[(t)-384.4(public)-399.9(prole)-393.8(a)-0.6(nd)-396.3(interest,)]TJ
-11.5091 -1.2527 TD
-0.0005 Tc
[(and)-588.8(t)1.3(here)-586.4(have)-592.4(been)-588.8(nine)-592.4(in)-588.8(total)-589.7(i)0.5(n)-588.8(t)1.3(he)-592.4(four-year)]TJ
T*
-0.0002 Tc
[(period.)-354.6(As)-352(detailed)-353.6(i)0.8(n)-353.6(C)-0.9(rosstabs)-352(12,)-360.6(three)-351.2(c)-1.9(ases)-346(in)-353.6(this)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
[(rst)-353.8(category)-361.4(of)-359.8(substantive)-363.2(nal)-360.6(j)0.8(udgments)-370(h)1.7(ave)-357.2(been)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0008 Tc
[(successful,)-192.6(a)-0.7(lthough,)-210.6(with)-209.7(the)-201.2(e)-2.5(xception)-203.6(of)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
18.146 0 TD
0.0001 Tc
[(Healthcare)-200.3(at)]TJ
-18.146 -1.2467 TD
-0.0019 Tc
(Home)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
2.662 0 TD
-0.0001 Tc
[(,)-300.3(t)1.7(here)-296.9(have)-296.9(as)-291.6(yet)-299.5(b)1.8(een)-293.3(no)-293.3(awards)-297.7(of)-299.5(damages)-297.7(i)0.9(n)]TJ
-2.662 -1.2527 TD
-0.0009 Tc
[(a)-229.6(U)-1.6(K)-230.5(c)-2.6(ourt.)-228.8(In)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
6.3056 0 TD
-0.0005 Tc
[(Calor)-225.8(G)1.4(as)-231.8(Ltd)-233.5(v)-229.2(Express)-225.8(Fuels)-231.8(\(Scotland\))]TJ
-6.3056 -1.2467 TD
-0.0002 Tc
(Ltd)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.5538 0 TD
0 Tc
(,)Tj
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 379.14 579.6901 Tm
(2)Tj
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 386.4 576.09 Tm
-0.0003 Tc
[(Calor,)-342.6(the)-345.3(m)0.6(arket)-341.8(l)0.7(eaders)-340(in)-341.7(the)-345.3(d)1.6(istribution)-353.7(a)-0.2(nd)]TJ
-2.5596 -1.2527 TD
-0.0006 Tc
[(supply)-536.5(o)1.3(f)-534.8(bulk)-540.7(a)-0.5(nd)-534.7(cylinder)-533(liqueed)-540.7(p)1.3(etroleum)-535.7(gas)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0003 Tc
[(\(LPG\))-378(i)0.7(n)-377.8(G)0.8(reat)-371.9(Britain,)-378.8(with)-377.8(circa)-367.5(a)-373.6(50)-377.8(per)-370.1(cent)-371.9(s)-2.8(hare)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0007 Tc
[(of)-504.8(the)-502.2(c)-2.4(ylinder)-509.1(L)2(PG)-505.5(market,)-499.6(d)1.2(istributed)-510.7(its)-503(p)1.2(roducts)]TJ
T*
-0.0008 Tc
[(through)-269.9(a)-259.6(network)-269.9(o)1.1(f)-264(i)0.2(ndepe)]TJ
12.3282 0 TD
0.0001 Tc
[(ndent)-269.2(dealers)-261.3(a)0.2(nd)-263(retailers.)]TJ
-12.3282 -1.2467 TD
0.0002 Tc
[(The)-320.7(d)2.1(ealers)-312(contract)-323.3(with)-323.1(Calor)-321.5(h)2.1(ad)-323.1(two)-323.1(k)2.1(ey)-324.9(features:)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0002 Tc
[(for)-213.5(t)1.6(he)-212.7(duration)-215.1(o)1.7(f)-215.2(t)1.6(he)-212.7(agreement)-203.2(d)1.7(ealers)-207.4(could)-215.1(purchase)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0008 Tc
[(and)-372.3(s)-3.3(ell)-367.2(only)-374.1(C)-1.5(alor)-370.6(cylinder)-370.6(L)1.9(PG;)-373.2(a)-0.7(nd)-372.3(they)-374.1(undertook)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
[(not)-643.5(to)-637.3(handle)-640.9(C)-1.5(alor)-641.7(cylinders)-635.6(after)-641.7(t)1(ermination)-643.3(of)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0003 Tc
[(the)-489.8(c)-2(ontract.)-487.2(T)-2.8(he)-483.8(defender)-484.6(t)1.5(erminated)-486.2(t)1.5(he)-489.8(agreement)]TJ
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 378.84 434.97 Tm
[(1)-558.6(O)-3(r)-273.9(p)-1.5(roof,)-272(a)2.7(s)-281.4(i)-0.9(t)-277.2(i)-0.9(s)-281.4(known)-272.5(i)-0.9(n)-280(S)2.7(cots)-281.4(law.)]TJ
0 -1.1819 TD
0 Tc
(2)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.1142 0 TD
0.0001 Tc
[(Calor)-725.1(G)-2.5(as)-732.6(Ltd)-723.7(v)-734.5(Express)-717.5(Fuels)-725.1(\(Scotland\))-735.9(Ltd)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
23.6233 0 TD
0.0006 Tc
([2008])Tj
-24.7375 -1.1894 TD
[(C.S.O.H.)-270.9(13.)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 360.9 383.25 Tm
-0.0009 Tc
[(Table)-279.6(6)1(:)-1005.7(S)-0.8(tage)-279.6(of)-282.2(litigation)]TJ
ET
q
0.42 0 0 -15.66 630.174 182.4361 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
19.5 0 0 -0.42 630.5939 182.4361 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F7 1 Tf
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 632.58 172.5901 Tm
0.0007 Tc
(AQ1)Tj
ET
q
19.5 0 0 -0.42 630.5939 167.1961 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
0.42 0 0 -15.66 650.0339 182.4361 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
0.42 0 0 -15.66 630.174 167.4961 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
19.5 0 0 -0.42 630.5939 167.4961 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 632.58 157.6501 Tm
(AQ2)Tj
ET
q
19.5 0 0 -0.42 630.5939 152.2561 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
0.42 0 0 -15.66 650.0339 167.4961 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
238.14 0 0 -0.54 360.894 371.0761 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F1 1 Tf
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 360.9 360.8701 Tm
-0.0009 Tc
[(Stage)-279.6(of)-15458.9(Cumulative)]TJ
0 -1.349 TD
0.0001 Tc
[(litigation)-4587.1(F)2(requency)-1270.5(P)2(er)-279.4(cent)-2045.8(P)2(er)-279.4(cent)]TJ
ET
q
238.14 0 0 -0.54 360.894 342.6961 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F2 1 Tf
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 360.9 330.5101 Tm
-0.0009 Tc
[(Substantive)-285.6(nal)]TJ
0.9997 -1.2527 TD
-0.001 Tc
(judgment)Tj
9.6902 1.2527 TD
-0.0016 Tc
[(9)-3968.5(22.0)-3552.9(22.0)]TJ
-10.6899 -2.9028 TD
0.0002 Tc
(Summary)Tj
0.9997 -1.2467 TD
-0.0012 Tc
[(judgment)-282.5(for)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0011 Tc
[(defendant)-282.4(to)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0009 Tc
(competition)Tj
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0001 Tc
(claim)Tj
9.6902 4.9987 TD
-0.0014 Tc
[(2)-4522.4(4)0.5(.8)-3552.8(26.8)]TJ
-10.6899 -6.6488 TD
0.0002 Tc
(Summary)Tj
0.9997 -1.2467 TD
-0.0012 Tc
[(judgment)-282.5(for)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0009 Tc
[(claimant)-282.2(to)]TJ
T*
(competition)Tj
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0001 Tc
(defence)Tj
9.6902 4.9987 TD
-0.0016 Tc
[(6)-3968.5(14.6)-3552.9(41.4)]TJ
-10.6899 -6.6488 TD
-0.0004 Tc
[(Interim)-276.5(p)1.5(rocess)-3526(2)1.5(4)-3967.3(58.5)-2997.7(100.0)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
0 -1.6502 TD
-0.0012 Tc
[(Total)-7751.2(4)0.7(1)-3414(100.0)]TJ
ET
q
238.14 0 0 -0.54 360.894 147.9361 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F2 1 Tf
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 219.18 111.51 Tm
0.0002 Tc
[([2009])-299.2(G.C.L.R.,)-253.8(I)1(SSUE)-272.1(3)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
11.4426 0 TD
0 Tc
()Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.074 0 TD
-0.0015 Tc
[(2009)-288.6(THOM)-5.2(S)-3.4(O)-1.6(N)-282.6(R)-2.2(E)-2.8(U)-2.2(TE)-2.8(RS)-274.4(\(L)-2.8(E)-2.8(G)-6.4(A)-3.2(L)-2.8(\))-270.7(L)-2.8(IM)-5.2(ITE)-2.8(D)-277.4(A)-3.2(N)-1.6(D)-277.4(C)-2.2(ONTRIB)-2.8(U)-2.2(TORS)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font << /F1 6 0 R /F2 7 0 R /F3 8 0 R /F4 9 0 R /F5 10 0 R /F6 11 0 R /F7 12 0 R
/F8 13 0 R >>
/XObject << /Im1 14 0 R /Im3 15 0 R >>
/ExtGState << /GS1 16 0 R /GS2 17 0 R >>
/Properties << /MC1 2 0 R >>
>>
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 40
/LastChar 121
/Widths [ 333 333 556 556 278 333 278 389 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556
556 278 278 556 556 556 444 800 722 667 722 778 611 556 778 833
333 389 722 611 1000 833 834 556 834 722 500 722 778 722 1000 778
722 722 333 389 333 556 500 278 500 556 444 556 444 333 500 556
278 278 556 278 833 556 556 556 556 389 389 333 556 500 778 556
500 ]
/Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding
/BaseFont /FHIKMG+Sabon-Bold
/FontDescriptor 81 0 R
>>
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 30
/LastChar 163
/Widths [ 556 556 278 333 556 556 556 1000 944 278 333 333 556 556 278 333
278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 556 556
556 444 800 721 611 722 778 611 557 778 834 332 389 722 611 1000
833 833 556 833 722 500 666 722 723 1000 778 722 722 333 278 333
556 500 278 500 556 444 556 444 333 500 556 278 278 556 278 832
556 556 556 556 389 389 333 556 500 778 556 500 444 333 222 333
556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 278 278 0 0 0 500 1000 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 278 0 556 556 ]
/Encoding 93 0 R
/BaseFont /FHIKNB+Sabon-Roman
/FontDescriptor 77 0 R
>>
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 48
/LastChar 151
/Widths [ 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 600 600 600 556 800
685 704 741 741 648 593 759 741 295 556 722 593 907 741 778 667
778 722 649 611 741 630 944 667 667 648 333 371 333 600 500 259
574 611 574 611 574 333 611 593 258 278 574 258 906 593 611 611
611 389 537 352 593 520 814 537 519 519 333 223 333 600 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 1000 ]
/Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding
/BaseFont /FHIKNN+HelveticaNeue-Bold
/FontDescriptor 85 0 R
>>
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 40
/LastChar 121
/Widths [ 259 259 352 600 278 389 278 333 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556
556 278 278 600 600 600 556 800 667 685 722 704 611 574 759 722
259 519 667 556 870 722 759 648 759 685 648 574 722 611 926 611
611 611 259 333 259 600 500 222 519 593 537 593 537 296 574 556
222 222 481 222 852 556 574 593 593 333 481 315 556 481 759 481
481 ]
/Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding
/BaseFont /FHIKOH+HelveticaNeue-Italic
/FontDescriptor 73 0 R
>>
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 42
/LastChar 42
/Widths [ 352 ]
/Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding
/BaseFont /FHIKOP+HelveticaNeue-Roman
/FontDescriptor 87 0 R
>>
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 30
/LastChar 146
/Widths [ 556 0 278 333 556 556 556 1000 944 278 333 333 556 556 278 333 278
278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 556 556 556
444 800 722 667 722 833 667 556 833 833 389 389 722 667 944 833
889 611 889 722 500 667 778 722 1000 778 667 722 333 278 333 556
500 278 500 556 444 556 444 333 500 556 278 278 556 278 833 556
556 556 556 389 389 333 556 500 778 556 500 444 333 222 333 556
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 278 ]
/Encoding 93 0 R
/BaseFont /FHILGB+Sabon-Italic
/FontDescriptor 83 0 R
>>
endobj
12 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 49
/LastChar 81
/Widths [ 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444 921 722
667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722 556 722
]
/Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding
/BaseFont /FHILKE+Times-Roman
/FontDescriptor 91 0 R
>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 1
/LastChar 1
/Widths [ 790 ]
/Encoding 94 0 R
/BaseFont /FHILMI+Symbol
/FontDescriptor 89 0 R
/ToUnicode 95 0 R
>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<< /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Width 1 /Height 1 /BitsPerComponent 1
/ImageMask true /Length 2 >>
stream
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<< /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Width 140 /Height 78 /BitsPerComponent 8
/ColorSpace /DeviceGray /Length 10921 >>
stream
ʹĻ⻠|{z廬v{{ҦeVTRf߲_OY\Z^`deffgfedc`WXbj~͞wSA>?Tu֧yTCKMMRSQRUWVSPPVNCEPWoϠxTCBDZuңuR@FHJPOSSVYWQPTOF;>HNhɜwUDBCWu`PTUWZVVRRURMQZZVPR[`x˞yWEA?Rpåyl_VPPMKWit|}ĿТ|ZHDCWsʸ|m^SPLOc}Ҹ̞xVFEG\}ͭsaQLINhУ}[JGFZx}`UJEPiУ}[JGFZx}`UJEPiУ}[JGFZxá}`UJEPiҶУ}[JGFZxŢ}`UJEPiĦУ}[JGFZxţ}`UJEPiֹУ}[JGFZxŢ}`UJEPi̼űУ}[JGFZxĢ}`UJEPiҺУ}[JGFZxġ}`UJEPiƵΠ{XHFF[tġ|_SHDOhν伧Π{XHFF[rġ|_SHDOhƽۮΠ{XHFF[xġ|_SHDOh¿СΠ{XHFF[yġ|_SHDOhʹÚΠ{XHFF[tġ|_SHDOhϾϲΠ{XHFF[zġ|_SHDOh¼ηΠ{XHFF[|ġ|_SHDOhΠ{XHFF[oġ|_SHDOhɻᭋ͠yaJBOYsŞ~^QFESlĶס̟x`JDOV_j}ơz[PFEQiϽ˒r{͟v]JFORY_hqvwutnhgo~ŠwYNFDOeоkyϟrWEDMNLNQUXZ\\TMJP`}uVJA?Jaнk|̝oQ?BLLJIIIJLOPHA=DTs㾘uUH=;G_Իϯmˣz]LPZYZYVSRRSTPHEM_}ġaUKISiپxmַpt~{srpmlkkkmd`gxӵxqnuöql̵ƶ«yvƿ«vuústй|quֻzpuôxnrvilètegƸr[]|ƴqXWté~oSPhƲ~oRJ\λuUHRuIJyy]IIaȾyu{gLBOiõnN=CYsϽzsmzδZFDH\sƹ}uor{cKFFN]{ʽԥx]OIIM[rŧ~rljjlx{bQNIKXi~ĵznfgnuuz^PGBHS_o}zt|}}|}vYMCDHKPWeo}~xslfdeghqy⽝n\TPJHITX_gox~wpkh]\ZZ\cmsۿzj_TMLJIJMT\bfceilnmkjkkjhgfedknpsxªsdYUTQPOQRTRRQQQRTUZ]aejr{~pmhc_]\\\[[Z[\^_bhpyξĽ
endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/Type /ExtGState
/SA false
/SM 0.02
/OP false
/op false
/OPM 1
/BG2 /Default
/UCR2 /Default
/HT /Default
/TR2 /Default
>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/Type /ExtGState
/SA true
/SM 0.02
/OP false
/op false
/OPM 1
/BG2 /Default
/UCR2 /Default
/HT 72 0 R
/TR2 /Default
>>
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Kids [ 3 0 R 21 0 R 27 0 R 30 0 R 33 0 R 38 0 R 43 0 R 48 0 R 52 0 R 55 0 R
]
/Count 10
/Parent 61 0 R
>>
endobj
19 0 obj
<< /Length 769 >>
stream
g001.eps
endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/MetaData 19 0 R
/Title (g001.eps)
/Creator (Adobe Illustrator\(R\) 8.0)
/Author (Perumal)
>>
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Parent 18 0 R
/Resources 23 0 R
/Contents 22 0 R
/Thumb 110 0 R
>>
endobj
22 0 obj
<< /Length 12157 >>
stream
0 g
/GS1 gs
q
23.94 0 0 -0.54 18.294 889.176 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
0.54 0 0 -18.72 56.394 921.516 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
0 G
0 J 0 j 0.5 w 4 M []0 d
/GS2 gs
3 i
330.5 914.79 m
378.5 914.79 l
354.5 926.79 m
354.5 902.79 l
354.493 908.797 m
357.806 908.797 360.493 911.484 360.493 914.797 c
360.493 918.111 357.806 920.797 354.493 920.797 c
351.179 920.797 348.493 918.111 348.493 914.797 c
348.493 911.484 351.179 908.797 354.493 908.797 c
s
/GS1 gs
q
0.54 0 0 -18.72 652.134 921.516 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
23.94 0 0 -0.54 666.834 889.176 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
/GS2 gs
29.957 444.183 m
29.957 492.183 l
17.957 468.183 m
41.957 468.183 l
35.95 468.175 m
35.95 471.489 33.264 474.175 29.95 474.175 c
26.637 474.175 23.95 471.489 23.95 468.175 c
23.95 464.862 26.637 462.175 29.95 462.175 c
33.264 462.175 35.95 464.862 35.95 468.175 c
h
678.557 444.183 m
678.557 492.183 l
666.557 468.183 m
690.557 468.183 l
684.55 468.175 m
684.55 471.489 681.863 474.175 678.55 474.175 c
675.236 474.175 672.55 471.489 672.55 468.175 c
672.55 464.862 675.236 462.175 678.55 462.175 c
681.863 462.175 684.55 464.862 684.55 468.175 c
s
/GS1 gs
q
23.94 0 0 -0.54 18.294 47.3161 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
0.54 0 0 -18.72 56.394 32.6161 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
/GS2 gs
330.5 25.35 m
378.5 25.35 l
354.5 37.35 m
354.5 13.35 l
354.493 19.357 m
357.806 19.357 360.493 22.044 360.493 25.357 c
360.493 28.671 357.806 31.357 354.493 31.357 c
351.179 31.357 348.493 28.671 348.493 25.357 c
348.493 22.044 351.179 19.357 354.493 19.357 c
s
/GS1 gs
q
0.54 0 0 -18.72 652.134 32.6161 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
q
23.94 0 0 -0.54 666.834 47.3161 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F2 1 Tf
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 193.98 816.99 Tm
0.0002 Tc
0 Tw
[(RODGER:)-278.9(COMPETITION)-281(L)1.4(AW)-272.1(LITIGATION:)-286.4(UK)-279(COURT)-267.3(CASES)-282.7(20052008PART)-267.3(II:)-278.9([2009])-276.6(G.C.L.R.)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
49.1513 0 TD
0.0011 Tc
(137)Tj
ET
/EmbeddedDocument /MC2 BDC
/GS3 gs
q
350.28 0 0 266.04 166.54 511.17 cm
/Im2 Do
Q
EMC
BT
/F2 1 Tf
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 294.72 502.59 Tm
/GS1 gs
-0.0008 Tc
[(Chart)-276.1(6)1.1(:)-782.8(S)-0.7(tage)-279.5(of)-282.1(litigation)]TJ
-18.5373 -2.9872 TD
-0.0004 Tc
[(and)-504.4(e)-2.1(ntered)-492.3(a)-506.2(d)1.5(ealership)-498.3(with)-504.4(Flogas,)-505.3(but)-504.5(continued)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0007 Tc
[(to)-414.3(handle)-423.9(C)-1.4(alor)-412.7(cylinders.)-415.3(Calor)-418.7(s)-3.2(ought)-414.5(damages)-418.7(a)-0.6(nd)]TJ
T*
[(interdict,)-306.9(but)-306.1(the)-309.5(a)-0.6(ction)-305.9(w)0.4(as)-304.3(defended)-311.9(o)1.2(n)-305.9(t)1.1(he)-303.5(basis)-304.3(t)1.1(hat)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0009 Tc
[(the)-490.4(s)-3.4(ingle)-490.4(b)1(randing)-494.6(obligation)-498.8(f)0.9(or)-491.2(ve)-490.4(y)-0.8(ears)-479.1(and)-492.8(t)0.9(he)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0003 Tc
[(post-termination)-269.4(r)-2.8(estriction)-263.4(in)-257.3(the)-267(agreements)-261.7(were)-254.9(null)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0005 Tc
[(and)-444.2(v)-0.4(oid)-450.3(i)0.5(n)-450.3(a)-0.4(ccordance)-441.8(with)-450.3(art.81.)-451.2(It)-444.4(was)-448.6(h)1.4(eld)-444.2(t)1.3(hat)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0002 Tc
[(the)-297(t)1.6(win)-293.4(f)1.6(actors)-297.8(of)-293.5(market)-293.5(power)-291.7(and)-299.4(duration)-299.4(e)-1.9(nsured)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0014 Tc
(that:)Tj
8.9664 0 0 8.9664 127.98 365.1901 Tm
0.003 Tc
()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.5621 0 TD
0.3272 Tc
[(..)-6.7(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
1.8134 0 TD
0.0008 Tc
[(if)-322(a)-329(n)1.4(ationwide)-318(n)1.4(e)3.2(t)-0.8(work)-333.2(of)-328.7(princ)3.2(i)-2.2(pal)-323.4(d)1.4(e)3.2(a)-1.1(le)3.2(rs)-326.2(is)-326.2(tie)3.2(d)]TJ
-2.3755 -1.171 TD
0.0002 Tc
[(to)-266.9(the)-265.1(b)0.8(rand)-266.9(leader)-266.6(for)-266.6(a)-1.7(t)-262.3(l)-2.8(east)-269(ve)-265.1(y)-1.7(ears,)-270.5(this)-259.9(will)-263.8(restrict)]TJ
T*
0.0014 Tc
[(c)3.8(o)2(m)3.7(p)2(e)3.8(t)-0.2(ition,)-276(e)3.8(s)2.3(pe)3.8(c)3.8(i)-1.6(ally)-274.8(in)-272.4(a)-274.8(m)3.7(ature)-277.3(m)3.7(arke)3.8(t.)]TJ
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 300.36 347.4301 Tm
0 Tc
(3)Tj
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 110.04 321.7501 Tm
-0.0008 Tc
(In)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.331 0 TD
-0.0001 Tc
[(English,)-450.8(Welsh)-437.8(a)0(nd)-449.9(Scottish)-449.9(Railway)-445.6(Ltd)-449.9(v)-439.6(E.ON)]TJ
-1.331 -1.2467 TD
-0.0015 Tc
[(UK)-363.6(Plc)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
3.192 0 TD
0 Tc
(,)Tj
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 144.6 312.9301 Tm
(4)Tj
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 152.04 309.3301 Tm
-0.0006 Tc
[(the)-363.6(c)-2.3(laimant)-360.2(w)0.5(as)-364.4(an)-360(operator)-364.4(o)1.3(f)-360.2(bulk)-366(f)1.2(reight)]TJ
-4.2158 -1.2527 TD
-0.0003 Tc
[(services)-629.1(and)-642.8(t)1.5(he)-646.4(defendant)-643(was)-641.2(i)0.7(n)-642.8(t)1.5(he)-646.4(business)-641.2(o)1.6(f)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
[(electricity)-602.4(generation.)-607.6(In)-606.6(1997)-612.7(they)-602.4(entered)-606.7(a)-602.4(Coal)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0002 Tc
[(Carriage)-628.2(agreement)-624.8(\()1.6(CCA\).)-631.6(In)-636.7(2006,)-637.6(the)-634.2(O)1.7(f)19.6()1.7(ce)-640.3(of)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0005 Tc
[(Rail)-294.6(Regulation)-299.7(\(ORR\))-299.9(found)-299.7(that)-299.9(EWS)-301.5(h)1.4(ad)-299.7(foreclosed)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0004 Tc
[(the)-411.6(B)2.3(ritish)-408(coal)-409(haulage)-417.6(by)-409.8(rail)-409(market)-408.2(by)-409.8(abusing)-409.8(i)0.6(ts)]TJ
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 127.98 217.1101 Tm
0 Tc
(3)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.1066 0 TD
-0.0007 Tc
[(Calor)-485(G)-3.3(as)-477.4(Ltd)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
7.1668 0 TD
0 Tc
[([2008])-480(C.S.O.H.)-474.8(13)-475.4(at)-480([35].)-482.3(I)0.8(n)-475.4(r)-2.5(elation)-475.4(t)1.8(o)]TJ
-8.2734 -1.1894 TD
-0.0006 Tc
[(severability,)-279.7(it)-277.4(was)-281.6(noted)-280.2(that:)]TJ
6.9739 0 0 6.9739 139.92 196.7101 Tm
0.0016 Tc
[()4.3()4.3(t)-0.9(he)-328.7(proper)-323.5(a)2.6(pproach)-328.6(i)4.3(s)-332.1(to)-328.6(vi)4.3(ew)-338.9([the)-320.1(c)-1.8(l)4.3(a)2.6(use])-336.5(as)-332.1(an)-337.2(i)4.3(n)-1.6(tegral)-322.7(and)-337.2(non-)]TJ
0 -1.2905 TD
0.0021 Tc
[(s)3.9(e)-1.3(ver)3.9(a)3.1(bl)4.8(e)-216.4(p)-1.1(ar)3.9(t)-215.5(o)-1.1(f)-215.5(t)-0.4(he)-207.8(over)3.9(al)4.8(l)-218.9(a)3.1(nti)4.8(-)-0.4(competi)4.8(t)-0.4(i)4.8(v)3.1(e)-199.2(a)3.1(s)3.9(p)-1.1(ects)-202.6(o)-1.2(f)-215.5(t)-0.4(he)-216.4(agr)3.9(eement,)]TJ
0 -1.2819 TD
0.0022 Tc
[(and)-198.9(t)-0.3(hus)-193.9(i)4.9(t)-0.3(,)-193(a)3.2(l)4.9(ong)-203.3(w)5.9(i)4.9(th)-198.9(other)-193.8(r)4(el)4.9(evant)-198.2(c)-1.2(l)4.9(a)3.2(uses,)-193(i)4.9(s)-202.5(v)3.2(oi)4.9(d)-198.9(i)4.9(n)-207.5(t)-0.3(erms)-193.9(of)-198.2(Arti)4.9(cl)4.9(e)]TJ
0 -1.2905 TD
0.0029 Tc
[(81\(1\).)5.6()5.6()]TJ
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 127.98 156.8101 Tm
0 Tc
(4)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.1066 0 TD
[(English,)-467.3(Welsh)-467.8(a)3.1(nd)-467.8(Scottish)-475.4(Railway)-478.7(Ltd)-467.8(v)-471.1(E.ON)-469.4(UK)-467.4(Plc)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
-1.1066 -1.1819 TD
0.0008 Tc
[([2007])-276(EWHC)-270.9(599)-278.8(\(Comm\).)]TJ
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 360.9 472.83 Tm
-0.0006 Tc
[(dominant)-360.2(position)-360(b)1.3(y)-349.8(i)0.4(nter)-358.4(alia)-349.8(the)-357.6(e)-2.3(xclusionary)-349.8(terms)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
[(of)-432.6(the)-442(CCA.)-427.3(T)-3.2(hey)-434.2(w)0.4(ere)-430(ned)-438.4(4.1)-438.4(m)0.2(illion,)-439.4(and)-438.4(E)2(WS)]TJ
T*
-0.0005 Tc
[(and)-480.4(E)2.2(.ON)-486.4(t)1.3(hen)-486.4(d)1.4(isputed)-486.4(the)-484(CCA.)-475.3(E)2.2(WS)-482.2(applied)-486.4(f)1.3(or)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0002 Tc
[(a)-530.1(d)1.7(eclaration)-534.3(t)1.6(o)-534.3(t)1.6(he)-537.9(ef)19.6(fect)-528.4(that)-534.4(the)-537.9(O)1.7(RR)-530.9(Directions)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0003 Tc
[(rendered)-191.1(t)1.5(he)-206.7(CCA)-194.7(void.)-204.1(I)0.5(t)-203.3(w)0.8(as)-195.5(held)-203.1(that)-203.3(the)-200.7(e)-2(xclusionary)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
[(terms)-304(w)0.7(ere)-303.2(illegal)-312.6(and)-305.6(v)-0.3(oid)-311.6(a)-0.3(b)-305.6(i)0.6(nitio)-311.7(i)0.6(n)-311.6(t)1.4(erms)-304(of)-311.8(art.82,)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0007 Tc
[(and)-414.3(a)-0.6(lso)-408.3(s)-3.2(ubsequently)-416.1(in)-414.3(relation)-414.3(to)-414.3(Ch.2)]TJ
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 545.46 401.73 Tm
0 Tc
(5)Tj
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 549.3 398.07 Tm
0.0005 Tc
[(;)-414.1(t)2.3(hat)-413.3(t)2.3(here)]TJ
-18.9107 -1.2467 TD
-0.0003 Tc
[(could)-269.4(b)1.6(e)-267(n)1.6(o)-269.4(s)-2.8(everance)-260.9(of)-269.6(the)-267(e)-2(xclusionary)-271.2(term;)-264.3(a)-0.2(nd)-269.4(the)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0005 Tc
[(whole)-285.2(c)-2.2(ontract)-275.8(was)-280(v)-0.4(oid)-281.6(a)-0.4(nd)-281.6(unenforceable.)]TJ
0.9997 -1.2467 TD
0.0002 Tc
[(The)-453.2(nal)-456.5(successful)-450.5(case)-447.1(was)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
14.5987 0 TD
0 Tc
[(Atthe)-459.4(R)-0.7(aces)-448.1(Ltd)-449.8(v)]TJ
-15.5984 -1.2527 TD
0.0001 Tc
[(British)-612.3(Horseracing)-608.1(Board)-612.3(L)-1.4(td)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
14.2313 0 TD
0 Tc
(,)Tj
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 505.44 351.8701 Tm
(6)Tj
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 515.4 348.2701 Tm
-0.0009 Tc
[(although)-619.3(a)-0.8(s)-611.6(noted)]TJ
-15.5079 -1.2527 TD
-0.0006 Tc
[(above)-622.6(t)1.2(his)-629.4(w)0.5(as)-617.4(overturned)-619(on)-625(appeal.)-626(T)-3.1(he)-616.6(various)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
-0.0003 Tc
[(unsuccessful)-294.4(cases)-297.9(i)0.7(ncluded)-305.5(t)1.5(he)-303.1(rulings)-297.9(by)-307.3(the)-303.1(H)2.6(ouse)-303.1(o)1.6(f)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0023 Tc
[(Lor)-4.8(d)-0.4(s)-251.7(i)-1.3(n)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
3.8304 0 TD
0.0005 Tc
(Crehan)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
3.4148 0 TD
-0.0007 Tc
[(and)-251.7(t)1.1(he)-249.3(Court)-251.9(o)1.2(f)-251.9(A)-2.4(ppeal)-246.7(in)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.7681 0 TD
0.0003 Tc
(AttheRaces)Tj
-19.0132 -1.2467 TD
[(Ltd)-527.8(v)-529.6(British)-527.8(Horseracing)-523.5(Board)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
15.0082 0 TD
0 Tc
(.)Tj
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 513.18 302.0701 Tm
(7)Tj
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 522.3 298.4701 Tm
-0.0008 Tc
(In)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.4213 0 TD
0.0005 Tc
[(Chester)-525.9(C)-0.2(C)-524.2(v)]TJ
-17.6218 -1.2527 TD
0.0008 Tc
[(Arriva)-529.1(P)3.5(l)1.8(c)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
4.6434 0 TD
0 Tc
(,)Tj
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 409.92 289.6501 Tm
(8)Tj
9.9626 0 0 9.9626 419.1 285.9901 Tm
-0.0006 Tc
[(Chester)-533(s)-3.1(ought)-540.9(declarations,)-541.7(i)0.4(njunctions)]TJ
-5.8418 -1.2467 TD
-0.0002 Tc
[(and)-654.7(d)1.7(amages)-659.1(b)1.7(ased)-648.7(on)-660.8(the)-658.3(c)-1.9(laim)-649.7(that)-660.9(Arriva)-650.5(had)]TJ
0 -1.2527 TD
-0.0007 Tc
[(breached)-305.9(s.18)-305.9(of)-306.1(the)-315.5(C)-1.4(ompetition)-318(Act)-300.1(1998)-311.9(by)-313.7(abusing)]TJ
0 -1.2467 TD
[(its)-503(dominant)-510.9(position)-510.7(i)0.3(n)-504.7(t)1.1(he)-502.2(relevant)-498.8(bus)-509.1(market)-498.8(by)]TJ
7.9701 0 0 7.9701 378.84 223.1101 Tm
0.0004 Tc
[(5)-557.8(T)3.9(he)-240.7(courts)-243(are)-248.2(r)-2.1(equired)-234.1(t)2.2(o)-249.1(a)3.5(pply)-244.9(t)2.2(he)-248.2(doctrine)-240.7(o)-0.7(f)-246.3(s)-2.1(everance)-240.7(and)]TJ
0 -1.1894 TD
[(the)-331.1(s)-2.2(ame)-331.1(a)3.4(pproach)-339.6(is)-333.4(held)-332(to)-332(apply)-335.3(w)2.9(here)-331.1(a)-335.3(c)0.1(ontract)-336.7(is)-333.4(void)-332(by)]TJ
T*
0.0005 Tc
[(reason)-271.6(of)-276.3(art.82)-279.1(and)-279.1(t)2.3(he)-278.2(Ch.II)-277.3(p)-0.6(rohibition.)]TJ
T*
0 Tc
(6)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.1142 0 TD
0.0008 Tc
[(Atthe)-533.9(R)0.1(a)3.9(ces)-536.2(Ltd)-527.3(v)-538.1(British)-527.3(H)-1.8(orsera)3.9(cing)-523(Boa)3.9(r)-1.7(d)-527.3(L)-2.2(td)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
23.6233 0 TD
0.0006 Tc
([2005])Tj
-24.7375 -1.1819 TD
0.0005 Tc
[(EWHC)-271.2(3015)-279.1(\(Ch\).)]TJ
0 -1.1894 TD
0 Tc
(7)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.1142 0 TD
0.0005 Tc
[(AttheRaces)-378.4(Ltd)-384.5(v)-380.3(British)-369.5(H)-2.1(orseracing)-372.8(Board)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
20.0701 0 TD
0.0007 Tc
[([2005])-381.5(EWHC)]TJ
-21.1842 -1.1894 TD
[(3015)-233.8(\(Ch\))-246(and)-241.3([)2.5(2007])-238.4(EWCA)-241.9(Civ)-237.1(38;)-240.7(see)-232.8(a)3.8(lso)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
19.784 0 TD
0.0004 Tc
[(Ineos)-235.4(V)-0.3(iny)3.5(l)-0.1(s)-243(L)-2.6(td)-241.6(v)]TJ
-19.784 -1.1894 TD
0 Tc
[(Huntsman)-272.1(Petrochemicals)-273.5(\(UK)-286.8(L)-3(td\))]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
15.8844 0 TD
0.0005 Tc
[([2006])-276.3(EWHC)-278.7(1241)-271.6(\(Ch\).)]TJ
-15.8844 -1.1819 TD
0 Tc
(8)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
1.1142 0 TD
0.0002 Tc
[(Chester)-273.3(C)-0.5(C)-271.5(v)-282.7(Arriva)-275.2(Plc)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
10.7201 0 TD
0.0005 Tc
[([2007])-276.3(EWHC)-271.2(1373)-279.1(\(Ch\).)]TJ
5.9776 0 0 5.9776 219.18 111.51 Tm
0.0002 Tc
[([2009])-299.2(G.C.L.R.,)-253.8(I)1(SSUE)-272.1(3)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
11.4426 0 TD
0 Tc
()Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.074 0 TD
-0.0015 Tc
[(2009)-288.6(THOM)-5.2(S)-3.4(O)-1.6(N)-282.6(R)-2.2(E)-2.8(U)-2.2(TE)-2.8(RS)-274.4(\(L)-2.8(E)-2.8(G)-6.4(A)-3.2(L)-2.8(\))-270.7(L)-2.8(IM)-5.2(ITE)-2.8(D)-277.4(A)-3.2(N)-1.6(D)-277.4(C)-2.2(ONTRIB)-2.8(U)-2.2(TORS)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text /ImageB ]
/Font << /F1 6 0 R /F2 7 0 R /F6 11 0 R /F8 13 0 R /F9 24 0 R >>
/XObject << /Im1 14 0 R /Im2 25 0 R >>
/ExtGState << /GS1 16 0 R /GS2 17 0 R /GS3 26 0 R >>
/Properties << /MC2 20 0 R >>
>>
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/FirstChar 46
/LastChar 46
/Widths [ 275 ]
/Encoding 96 0 R
/BaseFont /FHIPFG+MTMI
/FontDescriptor 79 0 R
/ToUnicode 97 0 R
>>
endobj
25 0 obj
<< /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Width 973 /Height 739 /BitsPerComponent 8
/ColorSpace /DeviceGray /Length 719048 >>
stream
رÃbWbcbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcbbbbbcbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcbbbbbbcbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbabhlr! "_ *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 aj: be7 ca5 ca4 ca5 ca4 ca4 da5 ca5 ca4 da5 ca5 ca4 ca5 ca5 da5 ca5 da5 ca5 ca5 ca5 ca4 ca5 mcywvca5 POUbz=L_Ylca4 L(v@KW5pca4 ߢ^c1Rdfa5 ֤<\LY`4 7<-6<:zu