An evaluation of the use of electronic monitoring as a condition of bail in Scotland

Martin Knapp, Rennee Romeo, Sujith Dhanasiri; Barry, Monica and Malloch, Margaret and Moodie, Kristina and Nellis, Mike. (2007) An evaluation of the use of electronic monitoring as a condition of bail in Scotland. Scottish Executive, Edinburgh.

[thumbnail of strathprints018649]
Preview
 Text. Filename: strathprints018649.pdf
Accepted Author Manuscript
Download (1MB)| Preview

Abstract

The aims of the evaluation were to assess the implementation of EM bail in replacing custodial remands, and to conduct a cost analysis of EM bail in contrast to those given custody. The study included the collection of qualitative and quantitative data, matched comparison data and cost analysis. Interviews were conducted with 10 Steering Group members and 45 professionals (comprising the police, social work, procurators fiscal, clerks of court, judges, sheriffs, defence agents, advocates, the electronic monitoring companies and victims' agencies). Interviews with 16 bailees and 15 household members were also undertaken. Quantitative data were collected from various sources, namely: court pro formas, Reliance/Serco databases, court files, social work files, police records, Scottish Criminal Record Office and data provided by the Scottish Executive Justice Statistics Branch, the Scottish Court Service and the Scottish Prison Service. Data from 3 comparison sheriff courts also provided a range of information on accused remanded in custody or bailed with or without conditions in areas outwith the pilot sites to ascertain whether EM bail is being used as a direct alternative to custodial remand and to explore differences in final sentences for the 2 groups.

CORE (COnnecting REpositories)